Rankings · April 10, 2026 · 4 min read
The best hotels in New York, rated by people who stayed there
From Midtown to Brooklyn: a ranking by guest rating that mixes categories together, with a direct link to every hotel page.
New York offers a bit of everything, from the grand Midtown classic to the smaller, more curated address in Brooklyn, and prices between the two experiences can be surprisingly close. This ranking sorts the city's hotels by guest rating, without assuming the most famous name is automatically the best choice.
The list below updates automatically from our live catalog. Every hotel links to its own dedicated page, with photos, a description, and booking platform prices compared side by side.
- 1
Motto by Hilton New York City ChelseaNew York, US★★★★10.0 - 2
LUMA Hotel - Times SquareNew York, US★★★★10.0 - 3
Henry Norman HotelBrooklyn, US★★★★10.0 - 4
Moxy NYC Lower East SideNew York, US★★★★9.6 - 5
Park Terrace HotelNew York, US★★★★9.6 - 6
Moxy NYC East VillageNew York, US★★★★9.6 - 7
Arlo MidtownNew York, US★★★★9.4 - 8
Moxy NYC ChelseaNew York, US★★★★9.4 - 9
Ace Hotel BrooklynBrooklyn, US★★★★9.4 - 10
Roxy Hotel New YorkNew York, US★★★★9.4
Edenfinder
Paradise has a price. We find it lower.
We compare prices for the same hotels across every major booking platform, with direct links to the right page.
Search your hotel →